March7
Just in case you have no idea what I’m talking about, I recently held THIS CONTEST to give writers a chance to win THIS BOOK (The The 3 A.M. Epiphany by Brian Kiteley) You can read all the entries in THIS POST.
Who were my judges? I will not reveal their names now or ever! Bwahahaha… Sorry, but I might use them again one day. I decided I didn’t want to judge them myself because I’d like to remain unbiased about my readers and writer friends. So you can’t be mad at me if you aren’t winning the book!
I will admit I had one female and one male judge for the entries. I also asked them to give me a pic to represent them in this post. You’ll see those below.
About the book: If you don’t win it, please purchase it at some point. The 3 A.M. Epiphany by Brian Kiteley is a wonderful book on writing exercises. This is the book that helped shape the first scene I ever wrote for my now 5th draft WIP. (Mallory’s Story) I couldn’t recommend a better tool for people needing a boost in their writing, a way through a writing block, or something to inspire them.
Let’s get to the big announcement!
And the winner is..
!!! AuburnAssassin (aka Claire Gillian) !!!
My judges did not speak to each other about the entries, and yet they BOTH picked lovely Claire as the winner.
Congrats, Claire! You can go here to read her entry. You will also see the comments from others on her story, if you go to the contest link I listed above. (Oh, and here is a link to her blog!)
I asked my judges to tell me a tiny bit about why they chose the winner and to also pick two honorable mentions. Their honorable mentions were entirely different. Says something, doesn’t it? You all entered very different and cool stories, making it hard to narrow down choices.
Let’s start with my female judge.

She said…
First place goes to AuburnAssassin. I thought this was a really funny look at what could have caused such an odd business name. And loved the twist! Clever!
Honorable mentions:
Kathleen- I could feel the old man’s desperation to capture the images and the importance in each click. It makes me really want to know the backstory – how he got here, the definite stakes involved, why the angel is trying to stop him. Great!
Soapdish- This one just drew me in. I could feel and see everything that was being described. It felt effortless, which is something I personally look for as a reader in terms of description.
Now for our male judge.

He said…
1st place goes to Auburn Assassin:
Off the charts on the fun scale and technically top-notch, this story was accessible, understandable and clever. Claire did a great little “shuck-and-jive” move that I appreciated just before the twist. And the twist! It played perfectly on my preconceptions and made me laugh out loud (and not a mere chuckle — this was a full-on guffaw)! Twist aside, Claire painted a layered scene with three unique characters — not an easy task in 250 words. This one is great on many levels, like a TV dramedy that is somehow simultaneously funny, truthful and meaningful, so it gets the win.
Madeline:
Awesome, awesome awesome — this story rendered itself in my imagination as two minutes from the 2nd act of a thrilling movie. I was hooked from the well executed in media res introduction to the decision at the end, and intrigued by the narrator’s shady motives. Madeline spent her 250 words wisely on a moment of choice for this “kid”, and left me wondering about all the right questions. What’s the hub? What are they after? Can I join?
BSB:
It only took one sentence for BSB to transport me into this fantastical world. Perhaps it’s the little girl’s point-of-view that does it — I’m still not sure — but this whole piece has a vibrant, sad, dream-like essence that is moving, even after multiple reads. I want to know more, but I’m a little afraid of what I’d find because there is clearly a darker, untold story here that the main character isn’t able to understand. It’s heart-breaking and beautiful.
Now for me!

What? I don’t get a pic, too??
Here are the thoughts I had independently from the judges.
Anne- “The zombies didn’t want to hear it, either.” Zombies. Yes. That’s awesome. I also liked, “He hoped their inside joke would crack her icy countenance, but she did not so much as blink.” Also, kudos for being a writer that doesn’t hesitate, Ms. First-to-Enter.
Madeleine- “I growled and grabbed his lanky hair, making him look up.” I liked that line the most.
AND I know Madeleine enough to be surprised that she took her story in the direction that she did. She thinks out of the box and is brave in her writing.
Kathleen- First favorite line wasn’t even in your story. You wrote, “There was a pink link. I clicked it. It led to a very un-pink photo.” Loved it.
I love short, to the point sentences like,”Dropped cameras meant delays.” I’m really interested in seeing where you might take this story if you had another 1,000 words to play with.
Erica- “Buddy where the hell ya been.” – Great. Just great.
I also thought the summer teeth thing was funny. But the worst part about yours? You don’t tell us where Buddy had been! (Ok, lie. That was the best part, but I still want to know the answer.
)
Damien- “This is a game now. I have to pull the words from her mouth like taffy. She won’t give them up.” – Loved that.
And I also really liked how you kept the story simple and relational, with natural sounding dialogue, but then you twist in a question. A teaser. :)
BSB- “Daddy never chimed. He was all tension and spring, but you’d never get a chime.” – Great lines. Very visual story while also showing us the relationships. You sucked me in with your phrasing and descriptions.
AuburnAssassin- “My sister had opinions as strong as the coffee she drank…” – Great line.
And I also loved the twist ending. Very funny and smart. It was strong and witty. (Congrats again!!)
Ryan- Award for shortest entry ever.
Lorena- “There were two men sitting at the other end of the mahogany table—Citizen Kane style.” -This is a nice reference and good imagery.
I liked that you had her clam up, rather than do the expected winning pitch at the end.
Amna- “Love didn’t taste sweet. Love didn’t smell great.” – Way to bring in the senses in your description.
I like how you thought out of the box and clearly started to see these character’s scenario with just a photo prompt.
Soapdish- “Jenny was greeted by distorted calliope music at the entrance to the fairgrounds, where a middle aged woman, with a bad perm and a cigarette dangling from cracked lips grabbed her arm and forced a red stamp on the underside of her wrist.” – Yep, you painted that picture very well.
I think you had one of the more abstract pictures and I’m excited to see how well you did with such a prompt.
Julie- “…I knew he appreciated the art of making movies.”- Lol Ok, NOT where I expected this picture to go. I love these story prompt examples where you can see how two totally different scenarios and stories are able to come out of the same picture. ”…comb the hood for that gray-haired hooligan and his camera full of nasties.”- Good line.
Mercedes- “He smiled, and felt the beautiful crescent smile as well. He began to row.” – Very mystical and lovely. Where did he row??
”He wanted to lick it up and take tiny nibbles…” – Great description in this line.
Heidi- Another with the more abstract photo.
I think those are the most fun pics, really. “The arms he’d wrapped me in had felt like my own. So connected.”- Good lines.
“Like blueberries with fur, he’d said…”- I see the imagery and the emotions in this.
To all of you, I want to say THANK YOU for making my first contest an awesome one!!! You all rock!
I’m hoping all participating writers were able to enjoy the prompts and the process of writing their entry. I will host another contest in the future and I hope you come back to play again.
*Claire- What’s your address so I can mail you the book? Email me!*